Few fixtures in English football stir as much emotion, tension, and history as the Merseyside Derby. When Liverpool and Everton meet, it’s not just about three points — it’s about bragging rights in a city where families are often split down the middle. Over the years, these matches have produced unforgettable moments, bone-crunching tackles, and moments of magic. But who has made the biggest impact on the scoresheet for Liverpool during these fiery contests in the Premier League era? The answer is a name etched in Anfield folklore.

Steven Gerrard: King of the Derby Goals

The player who has scored the most goals for Liverpool in Premier League Merseyside derbies is none other than club legend Steven Gerrard. The former Liverpool captain netted **9 goals** against Everton in the Premier League, making him the Reds’ top scorer in these high-stakes encounters during the modern era.

The Importance of Gerrard’s Goals

What made Gerrard’s derby goals so special wasn’t just the number, but the context. Time and time again, he delivered in matches where intensity was at its peak. His goals came in a variety of ways — screamers from outside the box, well-timed runs, and even a hat-trick at Anfield in March 2012, a performance that solidified his status as one of the greatest players in derby history.

Memorable Moments:

• March 2012 – Liverpool 3-0 Everton: Gerrard became the first player to score a hat-trick in the Merseyside derby since Ian Rush in 1982. It was a commanding performance, full of leadership and lethal finishing.

• March 2005 – Liverpool 2-1 Everton: Gerrard opened the scoring with a thumping low drive from outside the box, helping Liverpool secure a vital win in the race for the top four.

Why Gerrard Dominated the Derby

Gerrard was a boyhood Liverpool fan who understood exactly what the Merseyside derby meant. His leadership, passion, and ability to rise to the occasion made him the ultimate derby warrior. He thrived on pressure and always seemed to find extra fire in games against the Blues from across Stanley Park. His 9 goals stand as a testament to his influence and longevity in one of English football’s fiercest rivalries.

Other Notable Liverpool Scorers in the Derby

1. Robbie Fowler – 6 goals

The Toxteth-born striker was another local lad who loved a goal against Everton. Fowler scored six times against the Toffees in the Premier League, with his predatory instincts and sharp finishing proving vital in many of Liverpool’s derby wins in the 1990s.

2. Michael Owen – 4 goals

Owen was a thorn in Everton’s side during his early years at Anfield. He used his pace and clinical finishing to hurt the Blues, especially in the late 1990s and early 2000s.

3. Sadio Mané – 3 goals

In the Klopp era, Mané became one of the most reliable performers in derbies, scoring important goals — including the opener in the dramatic 5-2 win in December 2019, one of the highlights of Liverpool’s title-winning season.

Everton’s Perspective: Top Scorers Against Liverpool

For balance, it’s worth noting that Tim Cahill and Duncan Ferguson are two of Everton’s most consistent derby scorers in the Premier League era. Cahill scored 5 goals, often with his trademark headers, while Ferguson — a cult hero at Goodison Park — scored 4 times against the Reds.

Conclusion

Steven Gerrard’s dominance in Merseyside derbies is more than just a statistical achievement — it represents his deep connection with Liverpool, his fierce competitive spirit, and his ability to deliver when it mattered most. In the cauldron of derby-day intensity, Gerrard stood tall time and again, writing his name into the history books as Liverpool’s all-time leading scorer against Everton in the Premier League. For Liverpool fans, his goals weren’t just numbers — they were memories that will live on forever.

Other Articles